An antidote to the AI bubble popping

By: Philip MacKellar

Published: November 19, 2026

Is the stock market underpinned by an AI bubble?If the market is in a bubble, what would cause it to pop? And where should investors turn if it unravels?

Finding answers to these questions is important in light of the Anthropic IPO, Nvidia selloff and general stock market unease right now.

In all likelihood, this is a bubble, and possibly an epic one. The valuations for American indexes are high versus historical averages and are matching highs achieved during past bubbles. As valuations have climbed, the benchmarks have become concentrated. Roughly 37 per cent of the S&P 500 is tied to the information technology sector, while the Magnificent Seven (Apple, Amazon, Alphabet, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia and Tesla) account for around 34 per cent of the index.

Beyond markets, the estimated share of U.S. GDP tied to data centres has grown tenfold since 2019 and the sector accounted for roughly a quarter of the country’s GDP growth in the first quarter of this year. Furthermore, according to an October Brookings report, the AI build-out through 2032 could total US$10.3-trillion, or 3.6 per cent of GDP per year.

In comparison, U.S. railway construction accounted for 2.2 per cent of GDP annually during the peak of the railway boom between 1870 and 1890, and tech accounted for 1.1 per cent of GDP per year during the 1990s tech boom.

To fund development, companies are taking on debt, both on- and off-balance sheet. On-balance sheet leverage is growing fast, but the off-balance sheet numbers may be more of a concern. By some estimates, big tech market leaders have more than US$3-trillion in off-balance-sheet commitments. If the scale of the capex and leverage were not enough, the frontier labs are losing billions each quarter and the industry is bound together by Nvidia’s massive, opaque, circular financing whirlpool.

Finally, underpinning the AI trade is a compelling narrative. This drives investment but also fuels speculation. As was the case with past technology booms, AI will likely revolutionize society, and investors want to be involved. Unfortunately, calling a technological shift is the easy part. The hard part is financing the shift prudently. More often than not, companies overspend in an attempt to capture market share and beat the competition. This often leads investors and lenders to lower their standards and overestimate demand. As a result, the boom morphs into a bubble, and the bubble turns to bust.

Critics may dismiss the possibility of an AI bubble and argue aspects of the story are not being adequately considered. Even if the bubble argument is accepted, timing it is a whole other game. I, for one, cannot time it, but I can identify potential catalysts that could pop it.

The most obvious catalysts are boring old inflation and interest rates. As inflation and interest rates rise, as do the costs of inputs and borrowing. These trends dampen demand, increase investor scrutiny and make it harder to borrow. Other common catalysts are changes to the political landscape, taxation or regulation.

In the past few months, inflation and interest rates have picked up, and the midterm election result represents a paradigm shift. Data centre development specifically, and AI concerns more generally, were critical issues for many voters who emphatically rejected the status quo.

The market has also started to experience intense bouts of selling, as questions swirl over hyperscaler financing. Critical systems are facing repeated outages as AI accelerates vulnerability discovery. Private companies are also experiencing funding delays, as illustrated by the Anthropic IPO, and re-evaluations, as highlighted by pared-back OpenAI fundraising.

So, where should investors turn if the bubble pops? There are many possibilities: cash, bonds, hard assets, crypto, real estate and non-AI stocks are all candidates. In the aftermath of the tech bubble, stocks deemed irrelevant by the internet did well. Our best guess is that history will rhyme and that value stocks will represent an imperfect yet precious antidote for investors.

Within the world of value stocks, we are looking for corporations with strong balance sheets, low capex and meaningful cash flow generation. Cash flows are important because they support dividends, buybacks and business development. A company with good cash flow will also be at lower risk of requiring outside capital, which could be expensive or inaccessible during a crisis. Finally, a stock receives extra attention if it is outside the United States and China.

There are many companies with these characteristics. One that we own is Spark New Zealand. The enterprise is based in New Zealand, is the nation’s largest domestic telecom and fits our criteria.

Better yet, Spark has demonstrated the discipline needed to survive a bust. Rather than joining the data centre arms race, management capitalized on enthusiasm earlier this year by selling a 75-per-cent stake in its data centre division at 31 times EBITDA. Spark pocketed NZ$453-million to pay down debt and avoid the capex burden. Shareholders now own a deleveraged, cash-generating telecom trading at a fraction of that EBITDA multiple.

In the aftermath of the financial crisis, we owned Spark between 2010 and 2019. We bought at US$7.79 and eventually sold at US$14.79, while also receiving shares in Chorus Limited’s fixed-line network spinout, which we sold at US$19.49. Along the way, cumulative dividends exceeded our invested capital, and the total return ended up at 242 per cent.

Then it reappeared on our radar in 2024 as the New Zealand economy struggled after the pandemic. In March 2025, it re-entered our portfolio, and since then we have added to it three times. Our average purchase price is US$5.93, and our sell range is between US$12 and US$14. This target is lower than the last time around, reflecting the fact Spark can no longer spin off Chorus.

We are happy owning Spark and collecting the dividend as we wait, even if capital appreciation remains muted so long as money is being sucked into the AI trade. Nevertheless, Spark and value stocks like it represent a compelling antidote if the AI bubble pops.

Philip MacKellar is the general manager at Contra the Heard investment newsletter.